Fanfic Review Thread

[Spooky]

Now that fanworks have their own board, and fanfics have begun appearing, I figure we need somewhere to leave reviews, comments and praise for them, so here it is! Feel free to free-form it, just so long as you remember to state the title and author of the fic, or use the handy dandy review form below:

[b]Title:[/b]
[b]Author:[/b]
[b]Comments[/b]

[Shini]

Title: Storm and Safe Haven
Author: Tibby
Comments OMG. It's just amazing, it's fantastically written and intriguing and awesome and I want to read mooore and I love it!

[Deleted]

Title: Storm and Safe Haven
Author: Tibby
Comments I love your writing style. It’s very smooth and even though the reader has no idea what’s going on, it’s not confusing. I think you set everything up really well so it seems to flow seamlessly together. My favorite is trying to guess the characters before you name them. It’s like a game: Figure out the character before we get told! I also love that Costin is representing one of fathers against his other father. It also makes me wonder if other second genners are going to come into play. And that part about Arthur, which was sad, makes me wonder who the rest of the survivors are and who got turned. Also, it warms my heart to know that Beowulf’s looking out for all those people. I feel like a proud mother. I know he’ll do them some good.

Sorry, I totally just went all English major on you. I can’t help it. I’m sorry.

[Spooky]

Title: Storm and Safe Haven
Author: Tibby
Comments 'k, so I'm finally getting around to a formal review instead of just flailing on MSN, but man, this story. I was hooked the second I saw three of the principle players were Drac, Tulio and Costin, and every chapter just pulls me deeper in. I love how it flows, the switching back and forth between the past and the present, and gah, the suspense! As each little piece of the puzzle is revealed I'm just on the edge of my seat, itching for more. Brilliant job, hon!

[Dimitri]

*dusts off* Haven't had much in the way of fanfiction lately, so let's get creative, yeah?

Title: Heartless
Author: Bunny
Comments I am absolutely loving this so far. The character combinations and interactions are brilliant (special points to Chel/Tulio/Hermes/Dory/Remy/Charming, 'cause that is almost too much win for one room) and the plot is intriguing, and locking the wizards out of the action but not the equation is brilliant. I will definitely keep up with this one.

[telemain]

Title: Heartless
Author: Bunny
Comments I love how both Kay and Telemain are written. Kay is dead-on and Telemain is exactly what I was shooting for once he figures out how to dress himself and gets a little more self-confidence. Also, I love the way you write Dimitri.